Everton have had their 10-point deduction for breaching the Premier League’s profitability and sustainability rules (PSR) reduced to six points.
The club were referred to an independent commission in March for alleged breaches relating to the 2021-22 season and initially deducted 10 points in November.
Advertisement
The reduction of their points penalty will move Everton on to 25 points and up to 15th in the Premier League.
The club called the decision — the biggest in the competition’s history and first relating to financial fair play regulations — “wholly disproportionate and unjust” and appealed against it two weeks later.
That appeal has now been partially successful, with four of the 10 points restored.
| Position | Team | Games played | Points |
|---|---|---|---|
1 | 26 | 60 | |
2 | 26 | 59 | |
3 | 26 | 58 | |
4 | 26 | 52 | |
5 | 25 | 47 | |
6 | 26 | 44 | |
7 | 26 | 39 | |
8 | 26 | 38 | |
9 | 26 | 37 | |
10 | 25 | 36 | |
11 | 25 | 35 | |
12 | 26 | 32 | |
13 | 26 | 28 | |
14 | 25 | 28 | |
15 | 26 | 25* | |
16 | 25 | 25 | |
17 | 26 | 24 | |
18 | 25 | 20 | |
19 | 26 | 13 | |
20 | 26 | 13 | |
*Everton deducted six points |
A Premier League statement read: “An independent appeal board has concluded that the sanction for Everton FC’s breach of the Premier League’s profitability and sustainability rules (PSRs), for the period ending season 2021/22, will be an immediate six-point deduction.
“This follows the club’s appeal of an independent commission’s decision in November 2023 to impose a 10-point deduction for the club’s breach of the PSRs.
“The appeal was heard over three days earlier this month, by an appeal board comprising Sir Gary Hickinbottom (chair), Daniel Alexander KC and Katherine Apps KC.
“Everton FC appealed the sanction imposed against it on nine grounds, each of which related to the sanction rather than the fact of the breach, which the club admitted.
“Two of those nine grounds were upheld by the appeal board, which has substituted the original points deduction of 10 for six.
“This revised sanction has immediate effect and the Premier League table will be updated today to reflect this.”
Everton say they feel “vindicated” in their decision to appeal against the sanction and are “particularly pleased” the initial assessment that the club failed to act in utmost good faith has now been overturned.
A statement read: “Everton can confirm an appeal board has concluded that the points deduction imposed by an independent Premier League commission in November be reduced from 10 points to six points, with immediate effect.
Advertisement
“While the club is still digesting the appeal board’s decision, we are satisfied our appeal has resulted in a reduction in the points sanction.
“We understand the appeal board considered the 10-point deduction originally imposed to be inappropriate when assessed against the available benchmarks of which the club made the commission aware, including the position under the relevant EFL regulations, and the nine-point deduction that is imposed under the Premier League’s own rules in the event of insolvency.
“The club is also particularly pleased with the appeal board’s decision to overturn the original commission’s finding that the club failed to act in utmost good faith. That decision, along with reducing the points deduction, was an incredibly important point of principle for the club on appeal. The club, therefore, feels vindicated in pursuing its appeal.
“Notwithstanding the appeal board’s decision, and the positive outcome, the club remains fully committed to cooperating with the Premier League in respect of the ongoing proceedings brought for the accounting period ending in June 2023.
“The club is still considering the wider implications of the decision and will make no further comment at this time other than to place on record its thanks to our Fan Advisory Board and other fan groups throughout this process, and to all Evertonians for their ongoing support and patience.”
Everton's survival chances at 1pm on Monday: 83.6%
Everton's survival chances at 1.30pm on Monday: 95.6%The Opta supercomputer reacts to news of Everton's penalty being reduced from 10 points to six #EFC https://t.co/3eW558JtXx 🔗 pic.twitter.com/AiMGqZAxmP
— Opta Analyst (@OptaAnalyst) February 26, 2024
What this means for Everton
Analysis by Everton correspondent Patrick Boyland
This is undoubtedly a positive for the club.
They will view the reduction as vindication for their appeal and evidence that the initial verdict was disproportionate in nature. Although they admitted their breach, a punishment greater than that for administration felt on the harsh side and it was always hoped they would make substantial ground in this month’s proceedings.
Advertisement
This has been a tough period for everyone at the club, with manager Sean Dyche recently admitting that the uncertainty may have started to affect his players. On the pitch, Everton are without a league win since December 16 against Burnley.
It has felt like a club in purgatory, so Monday’s news is a welcome and much-needed boost.
Everton are still likely to be in a relegation battle, but the return of four valuable points moves them up to 15th and means they are now five points clear of the drop zone.
That in itself will be cause for celebration but it must be remembered that they are not out of the woods just yet. Their second PSR breach, for the cycle ending 2023, is set to be heard around April and that, too, will have potential ramifications for later this season.
All eyes now turn to that and the ongoing takeover process. Never a dull moment at Goodison, is there…?
How did we get here?
Everton were referred to the commission by the Premier League in March for the alleged breach, which concerns the PSR calculation for the three-year reporting period ending with the 2021-22 season. The league argued that Everton had losses of £124.5million ($155.2m) over the period, exceeding the limit of £105m allowed under the PSR.
Everton accepted that they had breached PSR, but only by £7.9m, and argued that they were mitigating circumstances for this, including the Covid-19 pandemic and their costly stadium build.
The initial hearing relating to the allegations took place over five days in October, with the commission including judge Alan Greenwood and Nick Igoe, West Ham United’s former financial director.
The appeal hearing began in late January and lasted a month, before the decision was announced on Monday.
What are profitability and sustainability rules?
Premier League clubs undergo yearly evaluations to ensure compliance with the league’s profitability and sustainability regulations.
This assessment is based on the club’s Profit and Sustainability Revenue (PSR) calculation, which aggregates their adjusted earnings before tax over the evaluation period.
Advertisement
League regulations stipulate a maximum allowable loss of £105m ($128.4m) over three years. However, Everton’s losses totaled £370million between 2018 and 2021.
In March, the club asserted in a statement their full confidence in their compliance with all financial rules and regulations.
What about the other PSR charge?
Everton could face a second points deduction this season after being charged with another breach of the Premier League’s PSR rules in January.
The Premier League said in a statement in January that this was “a result of sustaining losses above the permitted thresholds for the assessment period ending season 2022-23”.
While the figures for the 2022-23 season are yet to be disclosed, Everton suffered a staggering loss of £260m over the span of two Covid-19-impacted seasons. Adding to their financial woes, the club parted ways with manager Frank Lampard and suspended lucrative commercial partnerships with entities connected to sanctioned oligarch Alisher Usmanov amid the conflict in Ukraine.
The club finds itself in the unprecedented position of confronting two separate sanctions within a single season, leaving them vulnerable and compelled to wage battles on multiple fronts. The potential repercussions loom large, jeopardising Everton’s longstanding status in the top flight of English football.
Along with Everton, Nottingham Forest were also adjudged to have broken PSR rules. They signed 42 players since securing promotion in May 2022, with owner Evangelos Marinakis sanctioning a transfer spend of around £250million ($318m) to help the club establish themselves in the Premier League.
GO DEEPER
Assessing Everton's PSR arguments: Is double jeopardy a valid defence?
Have there been any other cases like this?
Manchester City were hit with more than 100 financial fair play charges last season.
The outcome in City’s case has not yet been communicated, with The Athletic reporting that a verdict — which would be subject to appeal — would likely take considerable time to be reached.
Last year, Chelsea’s new owners voluntarily disclosed incomplete financial information concerning transactions that occurred under the ownership of Roman Abramovich between 2012 and 2019.
In July, UEFA imposed a €10m (£8.6m, $11m) fine on the club for this historical breach. Meanwhile, both the Premier League and the Football Association are conducting ongoing investigations into the matter.
(Top photo: Tony McArdle/Everton FC via Getty Images)