Back in 2010, Us Weekly published a cover story that would eventually become a part of pop culture history. “Jake & Taylor IN LOVE!” the headline screamed, splashed across a photo of country-pop star Taylor Swift with one arm wrapped around actor Jake Gyllenhaal’s shoulder as he gripped her hand. It was a perfect fall day in Brooklyn on Thanksgiving. Swift was wearing a striped scarf and holding a maple latte (these facts will be important later), while Gyllenhaal was bundled up in a puffer jacket. They were both beaming, either pretending to ignore or blatantly showing off for the paparazzi cameras nearby, and really did look IN LOVE.