Monday, April 29, 2024
More
    Home Blog

    ChatGPT’s ‘hallucination’ problem hit with another privacy complaint in EU

    0

    Image Credits: OLIVIER DOULIERY / AFP / Getty Images

    OpenAI is facing another privacy complaint in the European Union. This one, which has been filed by privacy rights nonprofit noyb on behalf of an individual complainant, targets the inability of its AI chatbot ChatGPT to correct misinformation it generates about individuals.

    The tendency of GenAI tools to produce information that’s plain wrong has been well documented. But it also sets the technology on a collision course with the bloc’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) — which governs how the personal data of regional users can be processed.

    Penalties for GDPR compliance failures can reach up to 4% of global annual turnover. Rather more importantly for a resource-rich giant like OpenAI: Data protection regulators can order changes to how information is processed, so GDPR enforcement could reshape how generative AI tools are able to operate in the EU.

    OpenAI was already forced to make some changes after an early intervention by Italy’s data protection authority, which briefly forced a local shut down of ChatGPT back in 2023.

    Now noyb is filing the latest GDPR complaint against ChatGPT with the Austrian data protection authority on behalf of an unnamed complainant (described as a “public figure”) who found the AI chatbot produced an incorrect birth date for them.

    Under the GDPR, people in the EU have a suite of rights attached to information about them, including a right to have erroneous data corrected. noyb contends OpenAI is failing to comply with this obligation in respect of its chatbot’s output. It said the company refused the complainant’s request to rectify the incorrect birth date, responding that it was technically impossible for it to correct.

    Instead it offered to filter or block the data on certain prompts, such as the name of the complainant.

    OpenAI’s privacy policy states users who notice the AI chatbot has generated “factually inaccurate information about you” can submit a “correction request” through privacy.openai.com or by emailing dsar@openai.com. However, it caveats the line by warning: “Given the technical complexity of how our models work, we may not be able to correct the inaccuracy in every instance.”

    In that case, OpenAI suggests users request that it removes their personal information from ChatGPT’s output entirely — by filling out a web form.

    The problem for the AI giant is that GDPR rights are not à la carte. People in Europe have a right to request rectification. They also have a right to request deletion of their data. But, as noyb points out, it’s not for OpenAI to choose which of these rights are available.

    Other elements of the complaint focus on GDPR transparency concerns, with noyb contending OpenAI is unable to say where the data it generates on individuals comes from, nor what data the chatbot stores about people.

    This is important because, again, the regulation gives individuals a right to request such info by making a so-called subject access request (SAR). Per noyb, OpenAI did not adequately respond to the complainant’s SAR, failing to disclose any information about the data processed, its sources, or recipients.

    Commenting on the complaint in a statement, Maartje de Graaf, data protection lawyer at noyb, said: “Making up false information is quite problematic in itself. But when it comes to false information about individuals, there can be serious consequences. It’s clear that companies are currently unable to make chatbots like ChatGPT comply with EU law, when processing data about individuals. If a system cannot produce accurate and transparent results, it cannot be used to generate data about individuals. The technology has to follow the legal requirements, not the other way around.”

    The company said it’s asking the Austrian DPA to investigate the complaint about OpenAI’s data processing, as well as urging it to impose a fine to ensure future compliance. But it added that it’s “likely” the case will be dealt with via EU cooperation.

    OpenAI is facing a very similar complaint in Poland. Last September, the local data protection authority opened an investigation of ChatGPT following the complaint by a privacy and security researcher who also found he was unable to have incorrect information about him corrected by OpenAI. That complaint also accuses the AI giant of failing to comply with the regulation’s transparency requirements.

    The Italian data protection authority, meanwhile, still has an open investigation into ChatGPT. In January it produced a draft decision, saying then that it believes OpenAI has violated the GDPR in a number of ways, including in relation to the chatbot’s tendency to produce misinformation about people. The findings also pertain to other crux issues, such as the lawfulness of processing.

    The Italian authority gave OpenAI a month to respond to its findings. A final decision remains pending.

    Now, with another GDPR complaint fired at its chatbot, the risk of OpenAI facing a string of GDPR enforcements across different Member States has dialed up.

    Last fall the company opened a regional office in Dublin — in a move that looks intended to shrink its regulatory risk by having privacy complaints funneled by Ireland’s Data Protection Commission, thanks to a mechanism in the GDPR that’s intended to streamline oversight of cross-border complaints by funneling them to a single member state authority where the company is “main established.”



    Biden discusses hostage deal, reiterates ‘clear position’ on Rafah invasion in phone call with Netanyahu on Sunday

    0

    Reuters

    US President Joe Biden and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu



    CNN
     — 

    President Joe Biden and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday primarily discussed the release of hostages in Gaza, a source familiar with their phone call said.

    A White House readout of the call earlier Sunday said Biden had reiterated his “clear position” on a potential Israeli invasion of Rafah. While that was part of the call, which lasted just under an hour, the source said the focus was mostly on the talks to release hostages held by Hamas.

    The two leaders discussed the videos released last week of two Americans held hostage as well as Biden’s rare joint statement with leaders from 17 other countries, urging Hamas to accept the terms of the ceasefire and hostage deal, the source said.

    The White House also highlighted the two leaders’ conversation about humanitarian assistance. “The President and the Prime Minister also discussed increases in the delivery of humanitarian assistance into Gaza including through preparations to open new northern crossings starting this week,” according to the readout.

    The White House added, “The President stressed the need for this progress to be sustained and enhanced in full coordination with humanitarian organizations. The leaders discussed Rafah and the President reiterated his clear position.”

    The Biden administration has made clear to its Israeli counterparts that it wants to see a clear and actionable plan on how they would protect civilians in Rafah.

    Israel has told its US counterparts that it won’t launch an invasion where more than 1 million people are sheltering in the Gaza Strip’s southernmost city until the Biden administration can share its concerns, White House National Security communications adviser John Kirby told ABC on Sunday.

    Kirby said the US is still working on reaching an agreement that would include a temporary ceasefire and the release of hostages.

    “If we’re able to get this hostage deal in place — and we are still working at that, Hamas has not fully rejected it, they are considering this proposal on the table. If we can get that in place, then that gives you six weeks of peace. It gives you no fighting for six weeks, and that includes no fighting in Rafah,” Kirby said on ABC’s “This Week.”

    “And what we’re hoping is that after six weeks of a temporary ceasefire, we can maybe get something more enduring in place. We want to see an end to the conflict as soon as possible,” he added.

    Secretary of State Antony Blinken will be in the region this week to discuss with leaders the ceasefire and hostage talks between Israel and Hamas that remain stalled despite months of mediation by Qatar and Egypt.

    During his conversation with Netanyahu on Sunday, Biden also reaffirmed his “ironclad” commitment to Israel.

    The call took place just days after Biden signed into law an aid package that includes $26 billion for Israel. The package also includes nearly $61 billion in aid to Ukraine and $8 billion for the Indo-Pacific.

    “The President reaffirmed his ironclad commitment to Israel’s security following the successful defense against Iran’s unprecedented missile and drone attack earlier this month,” according to the White House.

    In a phone call between the two leaders earlier this month, Biden told Netanyahu that the overall humanitarian situation in Gaza is unacceptable and warned Israel to take steps to address the crisis or face consequences — a stark statement from Israel’s staunchest ally.

    This story and headline have been updated with additional developments.

    Solana-based tokens JUP and JTO hit key milestones: What about SOL?

    0
    • The market cap of JUP, the native token for Jupiter, crossed $1 billion.
    • Other protocols such as Jito also saw growth.

    Solana [SOL] managed to attract a large number of users to its ecosystem over the last few months. But it isn’t just SOL that has benefited from the influx of new users on the network.

    Decentralized exchanges (DEXes) such as Jupiter also witnessed immense growth, which translated into interest in the JUP token as well.

    From Jupiter to the Moon

    JUP was one of the top four newly issued tokens in 2024 with a market value exceeding $1 billion.  Over the last 24 hours itself, the price of JUP has grown by 6.04%. At press time, the token was trading at $1.04.

    Source: X/ThorHartvigsen

    The exchange also did really well in terms of overall transactions and activity, which surged significantly over the past month.

    Source: Dapp Radar

    A flourishing ecosystem

    But Jupiter Exchange wasn’t the only Solana protocol that was witnessing growth. Other protocols, such as Jito, also observed a spike in interest. Jito is a protocol that helps address stake their SOL.

    At press time, JTO, the native token for the Jito protocol, was trading at $3.18 and its price had surged by 5.97% over the past month.

    Despite the surge in price of both these tokens, the social activity around the tokens was showcasing negative signs over the last few weeks.

    AMBCrypto’s data revealed that the Social Volume and Weighted Sentiment for both JTO and JUP had declined significantly.

    This indicated that, despite the overall progress of these tokens, they had hit a bump in the road in terms of gaining popularity across social media platforms.

    It may take some time for these protocols to regain interest of the crypto sector in the future.

    Source: Santiment

    Despite the waning popularity of both these protocols and tokens, its progress pointed to the fact that not only is the Solana network is benefitting from its popularity, but its overall ecosystem is growing as well.


    Read Solana’s [SOL] Price Prediction 2024-25


    At press time, SOL was trading at $142.72 and its price had grown by 4.67%  in the last 24 hours. The volume at which SOL was trading at had also grown by 12.06% during this period.

    It remains to be seen whether SOL manages to maintain this rally in the long run.

    Source: Santiment

    Trump and DeSantis meet privately in Florida

    0

    Former president Donald Trump and Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis met privately Sunday morning in Miami, according to people familiar with the matter, breaking a years-long chill between the presumptive Republican nominee and his onetime chief primary rival.

    Allies brokered the meeting in hopes of a potential détente between the two men, and Trump’s advisers hope DeSantis will tap his donor network to help raise significant sums of money for the general election, the people familiar with the matter said. Like others interviewed for this story, the people spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe private deliberations.

    The pair met for several hours and DeSantis agreed to help Trump. The meeting was friendly, according to a person with direct knowledge.

    Trump and allied groups have lagged behind President Biden and his allies in the money chase. DeSantis has built a wide network of wealthy patrons whose assistance would be valuable in helping Trump try to close the gap, and is popular with some Republican voters who are exhausted by Trump.

    There is an incentive for DeSantis to form a closer relationship, as well. People close to DeSantis have said it is untenable for him to continue to have a strained relationship with Trump, particularly as he eyes his political future. He is widely viewed among Republican donors and consultants as weakened after a shellacking by Trump in the primary.

    The meeting was orchestrated by Steve Witkoff, a Florida real estate broker both men know, and he attended. Witkoff called the former president’s team and asked for him to meet with DeSantis, a person familiar with the matter said.

    Trump and DeSantis had not spoken since the end of a bruising primary, where DeSantis dropped out after a disappointing finish in Iowa, following months of attacks from Trump and his supporters. DeSantis offered a video endorsing Trump on the day he left the race.

    “It’s clear to me that a majority of Republican primary voters want to give Donald Trump another chance,” DeSantis said in a video message he posted that Sunday afternoon on the social media site X. “They watched his presidency get stymied by relentless resistance, and they see Democrats using lawfare to this day to attack him.”

    But DeSantis has not campaigned for Trump or helped him since, and in fact has made backhanded criticisms of Trump. DeSantis was stung by how Trump and his team treated him during the primary, people close to the Florida governor said.

    In a call with supporters in February after dropping out, DeSantis said Trump had political baggage and criticized some in Trump’s orbit.

    “I think he’s got people in his inner circle who were part of our orbit years ago that we fired, and I think some of that is they just have an ax to grind,” DeSantis said. The comments angered Trump’s team.

    At the time, Chris LaCivita, a top aide to Trump, called DeSantis a “sad little man.”

    DeSantis is widely loathed inside Trump’s orbit, but the former president has shown a willingness to be forgiving and remarkably transactional when it benefits him.

    “Will I be using the name Ron DeSanctimonious?” he said after DeSantis endorsed him. “I said that name is officially retired.”

    The two men have never been personally close, but Trump endorsed DeSantis in 2018 for governor of Florida — and once viewed him as a rising star in the party.

    In recent weeks, DeSantis held an event for donors at a resort in Florida, and people close to him said he is potentially interested in running for president again in 2028. During the Republican primary, Trump told advisers he wanted to hurt DeSantis for 2028, too. But he has moved his focus on to Biden and his criminal trial in recent weeks, and Trump allies say he would favorably view DeSantis raising money for him.

    Russia is making daily tactical gains in eastern Ukraine, as concerns swirl around Ukrainian military reporting

    0



    CNN
     — 

    Vladimir Putin’s forces have made further gains in at least three locations along the eastern front in Ukraine – including for the first time in several months an advance in the northern Kharkiv region – highlighting again Kyiv’s need for ammunition and weapons from the United States and other allies.

    Russia’s tactical advances are now daily and reflect the new tempo on the battlefield since the fall of the industrial town of Avdiivka in February.

    The gains are generally modest -– from a few hundred meters of territory to perhaps a kilometer at most – but they are usually taking place in several locations at once.

    Meanwhile, Ukraine’s losses are being accompanied by criticism from influential military bloggers and analysts of the armed forces’ official battlefield updates.

    One of Russia’s main efforts is in the Donetsk region. Ukraine’s DeepState monitoring group, which updates daily changes in frontline positions, shows Russian forces pushing forward in eight different locations along 20-25 kms of frontline in one 24-hour period.

    Military bloggers on both sides have reported that Russian forces have crossed a water course and taken control of the settlements of Semenivka and Berdychi – which Ukrainian army chief Oleksandr Syrskyi confirmed in a post on Telegram on Sunday. Russia had deployed up to four brigades in offensive operations in the area, Syrskyi said.

    A few kilometers to the north, Soloviove is now also reported to be in Russian hands, and the tiny settlement of Keramik at least partially so as well.

    “The withdrawal in the Donetsk operational zone continues,” the Ukrainian military blogger Myroshnykov wrote.

    Slightly further south, Russian forces are also making headway in the industrial town of Krasnohorivka, entering from the south and the east.

    Fierce fighting has been reported around the town’s large brick factory. One Russian military blogger wrote of the battle’s importance: “The liberation (sic) of the refractory plant would actually mean the fall of the Krasnohorivka fortification, as the northern outskirts of the settlement are private buildings, which will be too difficult to defend if the plant is lost.”

    Elsewhere, about 180kms (112 miles) to the north, Russia’s forces have also achieved their first successes in almost three months along that part of the frontline that cuts into Kharkiv region.

    A Ukrainian army spokesman described Russian forces there as having become “significantly more active” over the past day, while DeepState assessed a Russian advance of between one and two kilometers into the village of Kyslivka.

    Overall, the frontlines in this region have been among the most stable since Ukraine recaptured a large swath of territory in Kharkiv region in late summer of 2022.

    Stringer/Anadolu via Getty Images

    Utility workers clean up the aftermath of an overnight Russian rocket attack in the Ukrainian city of Kharkiv on April 27.

    With withdrawals and losses accumulating, military bloggers such as Myroshnykov and the DeepState site have both taken aim at official Ukrainian communications, accusing the armed forces of increasingly unrealistic updates from the battlefield.

    DeepState, in a post on Telegram, published a graphic video of a Russian soldier being killed in a drone strike in the village of Soloviove – but used the clip to argue that isolated incidents can mask the bigger picture, which it accused the military of doing as well.

    “You can watch with pleasure forever the video of a Russian (soldier) being torn to pieces,” DeepState wrote, “but nearby there is another location that requires attention: Muscovites calmly moving around the village, keeping it under control. The (Ukrainian) Defense Forces inflict fire damage on them, and one can repeat at least a billion times (on national television) that two-thirds of the village is under the control of the Ukrainian military, but the picture of reality is completely different.”

    That assessment – that two-thirds of Soloviove village was under Ukrainian control – was made by Nazar Voloshyn, spokesperson of the Khortytsia operational-strategic group, on Ukrainian TV on Saturday. Nearby Ocheretyne was also still two-thirds controlled by Ukraine, which had things in hand, he said.

    For its part, DeepState sees it differently, assessing that Russian troops have been in control of the center of Ocheretyne village, including the railway station, for at least three days. Last week, the monitoring site made a similar complaint against the military accusing “some spokespersons” of incompetence.

    Ukrainian army chief Syrskyi appeared to address those concerns in his Telegram post on Sunday suggesting that misunderstandings were due to the fluidity of developments.

    “There is a dynamic change in the situation, some positions change hands several times a day, which give rise to an ambiguous understanding of the situation,” he wrote.

    But he also acknowledged Ukraine’s overall situation had deteriorated.

    “The situation at the front has escalated. Trying to seize the strategic initiative and break through the front line, the enemy has concentrated its main efforts in several directions, creating a significant advantage in forces and in means,” he added.

    Narciso Contreras/Anadolu via Getty Images

    Ukrainian servicemen on an armored carrier return from the Semenivka battlefield near Avdiivka on March 4.

    Russia last made small gains in the region in late January and early February, but DeepState assesses a new advance of between one and two kilometers into the village of Kyslivka. Overall, the frontlines in this region have been relatively stable since Ukraine recaptured a large swath of territory in Kharkiv region in late summer of 2022.

    Russian forces are also making headway west of Donetsk city, entering the industrial town of Krasnohorivka from the south and the east.

    Fierce fighting has been reported around a large brick factory. One Russian military blogger wrote of the battle’s importance: “The liberation (sic) of the refractory plant would actually mean the fall of the Krasnohorivka fortification, as the northern outskirts of the settlement are private buildings, which will be too difficult to defend if the plant is lost.”

    Anatolii Stepanov/AFP/Getty Images

    Local residents sit at the entrance of an apartment building destroyed by shelling in Ocheretyne on April 15.

    Many Western analysts, along with Ukrainian officials, see Russia’s current stepped-up tempo as a precursor to a major offensive attempt later this spring. It is also assumed Moscow wants to take advantage of its significant advantage in ammunition before US supplies – greenlit last week after six months of political stasis – get to the frontlines.

    The Institute for the Study of War (ISW) assesses that there will be more short-term setbacks for Ukraine, though without major strategic defeats.

    “Russian forces will likely make significant tactical gains in the coming weeks as Ukraine waits for US security assistance to arrive at the front but remain unlikely to overwhelm Ukrainian defenses,” it wrote.

    Ukraine’s other major quantitative weakness, which also helps explain recent battlefield trajectories, is manpower. A new mobilization law comes into effect next month, which is expected to improve conscription processes. But Kyiv has proved highly reluctant to say clearly how many more soldiers it needs, while Moscow keeps increasing numbers.

    “The quality (of Russian fighters) of course varies, but the quantitative advantage is a serious problem, Rob Lee of Foreign Policy Research Institute, posted on X.

    “Without (its) manpower advantage, Russia’s artillery and airpower advantage would not be sufficient for Russia to make gains on the battlefield. The relative manpower situation is likely the most important factor that will determine the war’s trajectory, particularly if Russia can sustain recruiting 20-30k a month,” Lee adds.

    Time For ‘Destiny 2’ To Undo Its Industry-Worst Transmog System

    0

    Destiny 2 is in wish-granting genie mode as of late, blowing through a huge number of player requests over the last year, and the last few months especially. They are saying outright they want to do more of this, as seemingly they now have a greenlight from management to do whatever it takes to win the playerbase back.

    But would they dare touch…Eververse?

    I’ve spoken about this many times in the past, but if they’re actively taking requests, here we go. Destiny 2 has one of the worst transmog system in the history of the concept and it badly needs to reverse course to make it more player-friendly and just…logical.

    The current transmog system is a convoluted set of currencies that allow you to run activity bounties to get ten pieces of transmog per season, per character. It’s enough for perhaps two new armor sets a season, but sometimes there are more, and you will never catch up to get your full collection unlocked.

    Or at least not without paying. Unlimited transmog outside of that cap is $10 in the Eververse shop for each full set of armor. It’s the only way to both skip the grind and get past that cap. And it’s something that just seems outrageous compared to the larger industry.

    Even Diablo 4, a game that I have decried for its absurd volume and price of cosmetic transmog sets, allows you to instantly transmog any item you actually find in the game itself. While I am not saying Bungie should never sell Eververse armor ornaments, the same system should apply. You find armor in the game, you should be able to transmog that armor. The end.

    A long time ago, I said that they could keep the grind, just remove the cap. But I’ve changed my mind after seasons and seasons of these extremely dull bounties, and now in a situation like the present day, all I want to do is play Onslaught, but that doesn’t contribute toward my new ten transmog bounty cap at all, and I’d have to go run other stuff I’ve done a million times in the next month before The Final Shape and I lose my “free” ones. Forget it. Just make it all free, unlock it all.

    This reminds me of the consumable shader debacle which featured both paid and earned shaders, but in a way that was an exceedingly stupid grind paired with a way to get people burning currency in Eververse. Eventually, that was ended. You unlock a shader, you can use it an infinite number of times. It’s a similar principle with transmog, redesigning a basic cosmetic system to be logical and generous as opposed to squeezing blood from the monetization stone.

    It’s a popular request. My post under the “community manager asks for requests” tweet has the most likes of any others, and players have been beating this drum since transmog first existed. I hope this change is made, and even though I previously lost hope, I think there might be a chance with Bungie’s new philosophy.

    Follow me on Twitter, Threads, YouTube, and Instagram.

    Pick up my sci-fi novels the Herokiller series and The Earthborn Trilogy.

    Post Malone and Miranda Lambert Enlist Country Legends at Stagecoach

    0

    Willie Nelson’s classics-filled set and Charley Crockett’s vintage-worthy originals also drew a compelling connection between country’s past and present.

    Beyoncé did not show up. Reba did. And it was enough. At least it was for the 70,000 in Indio watching the Stagecoach festival live, if not necessarily all of the probably hundreds of thousands more tuned in at home strictly in hopes of a Bey sighting. As single ladies doubling up, Miranda Lambert and Reba McEntire may not quite have broken the internet the way a “Cowboy Carter” cameo would have, but in the flesh, it felt like their climactic three-song duets segment sure broke Stagecoach.

    Miranda Lambert and Reba McEntire perform at the T-Mobile Mane Stage during the 2024 Stagecoach Festival at Empire Polo Club on April 27, 2024 in Indio, California.
    Getty Images for Stagecoach

    And for his part, Post Malone did not need the help of any of the superstar artists whose albums he’s had featured appearances on to be a hit at Stagecoach. His penultimate set on the main stage Saturday was, as billed, a performance of all country covers (with a billboard on the way out to the festival site offering an 800 number where he was supposedly taking requests). He didn’t necessarily make any breaking news with his time on stage, unless good taste in Alan Jackson covers is news. But his emphasis on the 1990s/2000s hits of his childhood and youth (plus Tyler Childers, for good modern measure) would have captivated the crowd even without Dwight Yoakam, Brad Paisley and Sara Evans showing up to seal the deal.

    “How’s he doing?” Paisley asked the crowd of 75,000 during his extended time on stage. “I think he’s made for this.”

    Posty’s opening song, Childers’ 2013 “Purgatory,” nearly counted as an oldie, albeit one that may not have been familiar to everyone in the crowd. With its chorus references to cocaine, some fans who don’t know Childers’ catalog may have wondered if this was an obscure number from the ’70s outlaw-country movement. But from there on, there would have been nothing for anyone with the slightest grounding in turn-of-the-century mainstream country to not recognize. Before he was finished, Malone touched on some of country’s corniest sentimental songs (George Strait’s “Check Yes or No,” Tim McGraw’ “Don’t Take the Girl”), some of its corniest but funniest (Paisley’s “I’m Gonna Miss Her,” Toby Keith’s “Who’s Your Daddy”), one of its most rocking (Vince Gill’s “One More Last Chance”) and one of its most reverent and sobering (Randy Travis’ “Three Wooden Crosses”).

    He could have been mistaken for a true country traditionalist if not for his habit of inserting the F-word into literally every sentence, or close to it, between numbers. (Evans may have been the only person in his set who did not get an F-bomb as their new middle name, or at least a prefix.) But first up among his guests was Yoakam, who’d had the top spot in the Palomino tent the night before, walking out partway into “Little Ways.” Earlier in the set, Malone had done a little bit of wiggling, so it seemed clear he was familiar with Yoakam’s ouevre.

    Evans got the classic “Suds in the Bucket” all to herself as a lead vocalist, as Malone apparently decided he was not the one to tell a young woman’s story. (“Suds,” for any younger fans who may not be familiar with it, is basically the precursor to Taylor Swift’s “But Daddy I Love Him.”)

    But the most stage time was given over to MVP Paisley, who sidled up alongside Malone for a duet of the fish-over-ho’s anthem “I’m Gonna Miss Her,” stayed on stage to be a Gill proxy as guitar soloist on “One More Last Chance,” and then returned at set’s end for more fireworks on “Chattahoochie,” as Jelly Roll came out and sang along. Paisley may have gotten more soloing time than he bargained for; the set went several minutes past its scheduled ending time as Malone worked the ramp to sign autographs and pose for pictures, while the band, Paisley included, vamped through a very extended outro.

    By all rights, Lambert should have had a hard time following that. She did not. Even without the added power of a big McEntire attack, Lambert reminded the audience — song by song — that she has a strong a catalog as anyone in country music, and that on top of that, she has an hour and a half’s worth of rich, recognizable, high-concept bangers, with only “Bluebird,” “Tin Man” and obviously “The House That Built Me” built into the set as mellow moments. Her band played with a consistent rock ‘n’ roll fury, albeit with steel guitar licks now laden liberally over almost everything… to everything’s benefit. Whoever the entertainer of the year may be at any given recent point, Lambert has a strong claim on being country’s entertainer of the two-decades.

    “Drunk (and I Don’t Wanna Go Home)” was performed as a duet, albeit with Lambert’s backup singer, not Elle King, who had apparently moved on after playing the main stage Friday night. (King, who rearranged some of her material to better befit the rock band she’s out with, had done a less immediately recognizable version of their joint hit the night before, albeit still a good one.) Even though it represented a moment of shared and not individual glory in her career, Lambert’s “Drunk” felt like a natural set climax, especially when someone hit the pyro button for finale-suggestive fireworks.

    That wasn’t the case, as Lambert called out the need for “a sexy redhead from Oklahoma” to join her, and assuming there had not been a reconciliation and a hair coloring session with her ex, this meant McEntire, who braved the insane desert winds to join Lambert for a dynamite denouement. The hardest-rocking version ever of Reba’s “Fancy” was sandwiched between duet versions of “Mama’s Broken Heart” and “Gunpowder & Lead,” before the fireworks lever got pushed a second and final time. How potent it would be to get a co-headlining tour between these two, capped by an extended, explosive moment like the one this show ended with? Surely this space won’t be the first or last time where that idea gets floated.

    Miranda Lambert and Reba at Stagecoach
    Jeff Johnson

    Willie Nelson kept the “features” in his set to immediate family — as might have been guessed from the “Willie Nelson and Family” banner. It, too, was the source of some speculation about a Beyonce guest appearance, due to his recent appearance on “Cowboy Carter”… and because, you know, Beyonce casually sits in on other people’s acoustic-oriented sets so often. (Actually, sources insisted she was at Stagecoach undercover, to observe, just as she allegedly had snuck into Coachella earlier this month, but we’ll believe it when we… still don’t see it?)

    Willie Nelson at Stagecoach
    Chris Willman/Variety

    Whoever was tuning into Nelson’s set on the festival’s Prime Video/Twitch livestream just for the possibility of hearing Beyonce sing “Mamas, Don’t Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Cowboy Carters” got quite an inculcation into the most classic country of the last half-century. Hustling through 18 songs in just 45 minutes (if the closing instrumental of “I Saw the Light” during his final bows counts), Nelson established that, yes, OK, there are still living country superstars with even greater catalogs than Lambert’s. But for all the perennials like “Whiskey River” on view again — not to mention the still-underrated “Angel Flying Too Close to the Ground,” one of the greatest breakup songs ever written — the set’s highlight may have been the sound of Willie and Lukas sharing sublime family harmonies on Pearl Jam’s “Just Breathe.”

    Willie Nelson at Stagecoach
    Chris Willman/Variety

    Nelson has a hard time settling on reverence or irreverence — which is exactly as it should be, and as you’d hope — so the expected gospel finale of “Will the Circle Be Unbroken” and “I’ll Fly Away” was sandwiched right between two songs that take the piss out of everything, “Roll Me Up and Smoke Me When I Die” and “It’s Hard to Be Humble.” Nelson also brought out a few less mandatory songs from his early catalog, like “I Never Cared for You,” the least reciprocated song title in Stagecoach history.

    With Post Malone and Nelson both dressing down for the occasion, Lambert had the clear lead in the day’s best-dressed competition, decked out in gorgeous, turquoise-accented Western-wear (with a hat that surely had to have been crazy-glued onto her head, given the wind gusts she understandably kept remarking on). She had some competition there, of course, with the always stylist Charley Crockett, one of the highlights Saturday in the Palomino tent, where he made the most of original songs from his just-released “$10 Cowboy” album that recall country’s golden era as surely as Nelson’s tunes from that actual period did.

    Charley Crockett at Stagecoach
    Chris Willman/Variety

    Other highlights in Stagecoach’s hump day included an early-afternoon set from Tanner Adell, one of the featured artists on “Cowboy Carter,” establishing her own breakout potential; Maddie & Tae, getting their own set after getting the spotlight from Jelly Roll during his on Friday night; Asleep at the Wheel, bringing Ray Benson’s 50-plus venerable years of swing to the tent; and Leon Bridges, a welcome outlier from outside the genre — but a natural fit — as the day’s Palomino headliner. The Palomino was never more packed to overflowing than when “Yellowstone’s” Luke Grimes turned in a mid-afternoon set of material from his recent release (momentarily emptying Paramount+’s “Yellowstone” installation nearby), or for EDM carpetbagger Diplo’s after-hours set that allowed lingering festivalgoers to rave it up after Lambert’s rocking.

    Could Beyoncé still show up on Sunday? Anything’s possible — except for that happening during Morgan Wallen’s headlining set, because we’re pretty sure that is not possible. But Sunday does promise performances from three more artists who appeared on the “Cowboy Carter” album: Shaboozey, Willie Jones and Brittney Spencer. Other draws for Sunday include the War and Treaty, Megan Moroney, Clint Black, Bailey Zimmerman, Pam Tillis, Ashley Cooke, the Beach Boys and an after-hours closing set from Wiz Khalifa.

    Rant & Rave: Reader tired of BOGO advertising

    0

    RANT to the never-ending “buy one get one free” advertising come-on that so many businesses use to try to sell a product. They have run it into the ground and I, for one, will make every effort to avoid patronizing those businesses. Surely there are some creative people left that can do better.

    RAVE to the two people who came to my aid after I fell in front of my apartment building. After a day of much walking, my legs just gave out when I was picking something up that I had dropped and I couldn’t get up. They lifted me to a standing position so I could get into the building. They were so awesome and I want to thank them again.

    RANT to the folks who park on the east side of the street on 10th Avenue East between Denny and John during the Capitol Hill farmers market EVERY Sunday despite the “No Parking” signs. Illegally parked cars prevent firetrucks, ambulances, access vans and delivery trucks from getting through.

    RAVE to deodorant and lip balm that come in compostable cardboard tubes instead of plastic ones that are impossible to recycle! Rave also for toothpaste tablets in glass jars instead of impossible-to-recycle toothpaste tubes!

    RANT to baseball games in April. It’s freezing at T-Mobile Park, and 33 degrees and snowing at Coors Field in Denver. I wish the baseball season was shortened by two weeks, but I know it would never happen.

    RAVE to Mother Nature for putting on a spectacular tulip show this year and to the folks behind the Skagit Valley Tulip Festival for their hard work and organization to pull off a successful month of events up north. 

    RANT to people in the turn lane who leave two car-lengths or more in front of them, waiting for the light, causing traffic to back up behind them.

    RAVE to my indoor Christmas poinsettia plant, now 5 months old. It is healthy and still has all its red flowers and leaves. It came as a three-pack and the other two succumbed a long time ago. Maybe it will last until next Christmas?!

    RANT AND RAVE Rave to all the front-line pharmacy workers who have worked in stressful, understaffed situations even before the pandemic. Rant to customers who get angry when a pharmacist takes a lunch break or blames them for the drug shortages happening everywhere or are mad at the pharmacy when their insurance doesn’t cover their drug or when the doctor makes a mistake sending in the prescription. These pharmacy workers deserve our kudos, not derision!

    RAVE to the thoughtful person who, upon discovering I accidentally dropped my favorite sun hat, tucked it away so it was discreetly visible. You made my day when I retraced my steps and spotted it. Thank you so much for the day brightener!

    RAVE to Third Avenue for being only for buses. It makes being a pedestrian much less fraught. 

    Colorful birds make spring extra vibrant. But what gives them their hue

    0

    Birds boast some of the most vibrant colors among terrestrial animals. The tropics are often renowned for the brightest birds, but U.S. birds also display a wide array of striking hues.  

    But just how colorful are our avian friends?  

    USA TODAY analyzed over 500 photographs of bird species provided by the Macaulay Library at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, whose extensive media collection helps researchers identify and study color abnormalities and rare bird colors. The species were chosen based on data from Project FeederWatch, a citizen science program run by the Cornell Lab, which allows people to submit sightings of birds they’ve seen locally.

    Using a machine learning algorithm, we determined the dominant color of each bird photo. 

    Let’s take a look at the American kestrel, one of the smallest and most colorful falcons in the U.S. It can be spotted all over the country, soaring over open expanses while looking for insects to eat. Running the photo through a machine learning algorithm resulted in this color palette for the bird.

    The machine learning model determined that the dominant color for this bird is dark gray, which means this color group contained the most pixels. We ran this same analysis for all 559 bird species, resulting in a rainbow of colors representing U.S. birds.

    It’s important to mention that the dominant color we got depends on the lighting of the photo, the time of year it was taken, the sex of the bird and its age.

    Avian colors do more than just captivate human spectators. They also serve utilitarian purposes, indicating overall environmental quality and playing important roles in a bird’s survival and courtship behavior.

    “Birds are sentinels of the environment,” said Allison Shultz, the associate curator of ornithology at the Natural History Museums of Los Angeles County in California. 

    “The artist in me is what really fell in love with bird colors,” Shultz said, “but it was the biologist in me that discovered why they’re so important and that they’re actually worth studying.” 

    How do birds get their colors?  

    Understanding bird coloration combines biology and physics. There are two primary ways that birds get their color: pigmentation and the physical structure of the feather – sometimes a combination of both.  

    Pigments are the chemical substances in animal and plant cells that impart color, absorb and reflect certain wavelengths of light. 

    Birds acquire some pigments, such as carotenoids, by eating fruits, seeds, or insects. Carotenoids produce the bright reds, yellows, and oranges seen in birds, and they are the same pigments that give carrots and pumpkins their signature color. 

    The other way birds acquire their appearance is through structural colors, which result from the interaction of light with the microscopic structures in feathers. Tiny air bubbles within the feather refract and scatter light, creating vibrant colors for us to perceive.

    Picture the surface of a soap bubble or a rainbow-like oil slick. These phenomena, along with morpho butterflies’ brilliant blue wings, are examples of structural colors at play. 

    The northern cardinal, a classic red bird, has pigment in its feathers that absorbs all but the red wavelengths, which are then reflected to us. 

    Carotenoid-based colors are often used as an indicator of a male bird’s quality, Shultz said. Brighter colors are frequently associated with superior genes, stronger immune systems and higher reproductive success.  

    This concept, known as “redder is better,” reflects the idea that brighter birds make for better mates, said Richard Prum, an evolutionary ornithologist who teaches at Yale University. However, Prum disagrees and says the concept is a problematic way of “taking beauty in the world and turning it into utility.” 

    While several North American birds exhibit apparent green plumage, turacos, native to sub-Saharan Africa, stand out as the only birds that are truly green. Unlike other species, turacos owe their color to a copper-based pigment called turacoverdin. 

    The common grackle and many shimmering hummingbirds display iridescence like the way a prism splits light into a rainbow. Their iridescent feathers change color depending on the viewing angle, adding to the allure.   

    Colors of a bird 

    While bird species dazzle with myriad colors, a single bird usually has several colors itself, which our color palettes above don’t capture.  

    The colors that birds have boil down to evolutionary trade-offs and selective pressures, Prum said.  

    The strongest pressure is what drives a bird’s feathers to be a certain way, Shultz said, whether it’s to impress a mate, blend into the environment, or stay cool in a hot place. 

    While bright colors can be great for social and sexual signaling, they’re not as helpful for avoiding predators.  

    Bright pops of color tend to be signaling colors used for social interactions. It can be a way of saying, “Join my flock. We’re members of the same flock,” Prum said.  

    For this reason, these vibrant spots often appear on a bird’s crown, throat, or breast – areas that face other birds, Shultz said. A bird’s back is typically darker and more cryptic, aiding in camouflage. This adaptation, known as countershading, helps the bird blend in and avoid drawing attention to itself. 

    Male ruby-crowned kinglets, for example, can flash a scarlet-red crown when excited or keep it concealed when needed.  

    Feathers containing melanin are stronger, Shultz said, which is why birds often have dark wing feathers to aid them in flight. 

    Do colors change?

    Even within the same species, color can vary by age, season and sex.  

    Birds undergo molting, the process of shedding old feathers and growing new ones, which can result in color transformations. Most birds experience an annual molt, typically after the breeding season, Shultz said, but species like American goldfinches replace their feathers twice a year.  

    “If you’re looking at birds in certain times of year when they’re molting, they might look a little bit scraggly,” Shultz said. “That’s just because they’re growing new feathers.” 

    Molting helps birds maintain optimal feather condition for flight and allows them to replace worn-out feathers and remove parasites, Prum said. 

    Young birds might also look different than their older counterparts. That’s because it takes time for birds to signal sexual maturity. Most songbirds reach this state after one year, but bald eagles can take as long as five years to attain full adult plumage. 

    Males and females can have varying appearances – a phenomenon called sexual dimorphism. Females tend to be drabber because they have different ecological and social behavioral needs, although sometimes, the two sexes look identical, as seen in blue jays.  

    How do birds see colors?

    As colorful as birds are to the human eye, we’re actually “colorblind with respect to birds,” Prum said. That’s because birds see an even wider gamut of colors than humans can.  

    “Birds are living in a much more vibrant and colorful world than we are,” Shultz said. 

    Humans have three types of cones in our eyes for red, green and blue light. Birds have an added type of cone that allows them to see ultraviolet light.  

    In addition to seeing a broader spectrum of colors, birds can also detect finer differences between them. That means birds can distinguish subtle nuances in shades of green that are not perceptible to us. 

    “Everybody always asks me, ‘Could you make bird vision goggles?’” Shultz said. “And really, we can’t because our brains are just not set up to neurologically process that type of information.” 

    Curious to learn more about the birds you’ve seen in this story? Click on a color to find out.

    Contributing: Javier Zarracina

    Sources: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service National Digital Library, Getty Images.

    Methodology: Photos were manually selected to find images of birds in a similar pose, with good lighting and for overall quality. The background was removed from all photos and each photo was run through the K-means algorithm to get the dominant color. K-means works by dividing the colors of a bird into distinct groups, or ‘clusters’ to find the most representative colors. Each pixel’s color is then assigned to the nearest cluster center. The cluster with the most pixels becomes the dominant color.

    Are apples healthy? Plus here are the sweetest apples you can buy.

    0

    A version of the famous proverb “an apple a day keeps the doctor away” first appeared in the United States in 1866 in a New Hampshire-based magazine called Notes and Queries. Though older iterations of it might exist in other parts of the world, few repeaters of the proverb in century’s past likely understood the full extent of just how beneficial to health apples really are. 

    But apples aren’t necessarily unique among other fruits in all of the health benefits they have to offer. It turns out eating most any fruit or vegetable – along with other healthy foods, as part of a well-balanced diet – can similarly help to keep certain medical issues at bay. 

    Are apples healthy? 

    There are many proven health benefits that come from eating apples. A National Center for Biotechnology Information study, for instance, shows that regular apple consumption reduces one’s risk of developing lung cancer. “Research has also shown that the presence of polyphenols in apples has helped the fruit consistently be associated with a decreased risk of heart disease and type 2 diabetes,” says Abbie Gellman, a registered dietitian and New York City-based chef.

    Apple peels are also a great source of flavonoids, which help the body fight off viruses and inflammation and have been associated with a decreased risk of stroke. 

    Apples are also rich in vitamin C, “which helps destroy free radicals before they can damage cell membranes, DNA, and other body components,” explains Jill Weisenberger, MS, RDN, a Virginia-based registered dietician and author of “Prediabetes: A Complete Guide.” She adds that apples contain pectin as well, which helps lower LDL cholesterol levels.

    “Apples are high in fiber and antioxidants, which can help promote health and reduce risk for disease,” says Abby Langer, a clinical nutritionist, registered dietitian and founder of Abby Langer Nutrition. “They’re also good sources of carbohydrates, which gives us energy,” she adds.

    Eating apples can also help with healthy weight management because the snack is refreshing, satiating, low in calories, and “eating one can replace snacking on donuts, chips or ice cream,” says Weisenberger.

    Is apple juice good for you? ‘Applejuiceification’ is the internet’s latest controversy.

    Are apples healthier than other fruits? 

    Despite all their benefits, it wouldn’t be accurate to describe apples as necessarily being “healthier” than other fruits. “All fruits are nutritious, and the most nutritious diets will provide a large variety of fruits,” offers Weisenberger. For examples, she notes that pears have more fiber than apples, oranges have more vitamin C, and blueberries have a different mix of polyphenols. “That’s why eating a variety is the best way to go,” she says. 

    Langer agrees, so she says you shouldn’t feel limited if apples aren’t really your thing. “Choose whichever fruits you prefer to eat regularly,” she advises.

    Which apples are sweetest? 

    It might surprise you to know that there are over 7,500 varieties of apples grown worldwide, according to research from Washington State University. Some of the most popularly purchased varieties within the United States include Fuji apples, Red Delicious, Golden Delicious, Honeycrisp, Pink Lady, Jonagold, Gala, Macoum, McIntosh, Empire, and Granny Smith. 

    While sweetness levels can be subjective, Fuji apples are often considered the sweetest apple variety out there, followed by Gala, Honeycrisp, and Red Delicious. “Granny Smith apples tend to be less sweet and tart and hold their shape well, which makes them great for baking,” says Gellman. 

    Crisp, sweet, red, or green: Our visual guide to apple picking season this Fall

    When it comes to health benefits associated with each variety, “don’t let anyone tell you one apple is healthier than another,” advises Weisenberger. “Some will have more dietary fiber, but others will have more vitamin C,” she explains. “My best advice is to eat what you like, keep the skins on, and periodically try a different variety.”